How the traditions compare on the Holy Spirit
Where traditions agree, we don't list a row for it — this table is built around the specific questions that actually divide them.
- Are the sign gifts (tongues, prophecy, healing) active today?
- What is baptism in the Holy Spirit, and when does it happen?
- How central are experiential gifts to ordinary worship?
- Filioque — does the Spirit proceed from the Father alone, or the Father and the Son?
| Question | Catholic | Reformed / Confessional Protestant | Pentecostal / Charismatic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sign gifts active today? | Yes, via the charismatic renewal; not required or universal | Generally no (cessationist) or held cautiously | Yes, expected as ordinary church life |
| Baptism in the Spirit | Tied sacramentally to baptism/confirmation; renewal possible later | Generally understood as occurring at conversion | A distinct experience after conversion, often evidenced by tongues |
| Centrality of experiential gifts | Secondary to sacramental life; genuine but non-essential | Minimal to none in ordinary worship | Central and expected in regular church life |
| Filioque (Spirit's procession) | Affirms Father and Son (Western view) | Affirms Father and Son (Western view) | Affirms Father and Son (Western view) |
| Historical root of the tradition's Spirit teaching | Council of Constantinople (381) plus ongoing Magisterial teaching | Reformation-era confessions (16th-17th c.) building on Nicene doctrine | Topeka (1901) and Azusa Street (1906) revivals |
| View of tongues specifically | Permitted, not expected; regulated pastorally where practiced | Generally understood as ceased or exceptionally rare | Expected; often taught as the initial evidence of Spirit baptism |
What this table cannot tell you. This table describes each tradition's official or majority teaching as commonly summarized by scholars of that tradition — individual churches and pastors within any of these traditions may teach or practice differently. Eastern Orthodox teaching is covered in the article on how traditions compare, and differs from all three columns shown here specifically on the filioque question.
Go deeper than a table
Some links in this section are partner or affiliate links, and we may be paid a fee at no cost to you. It never changes what we recommend or the order anything appears in. Full disclosure · how we source this.